Letters Opinion

Saturday, April 16th, 2011 | Posted by Letters to the Editor

Supervisors’ action on trail is breaking hearts

EDITOR: Hey, wouldn’t it be great to take a train ride from El Dorado to Folsom this time of year when the fields are green and the wildflowers are prolific? That’s the dream of a group of enthusiastic volunteers who have been working for many years to see that very thing become a reality.

However, your El Dorado County Board of Supervisors is considering taking an action in the near future that will put an end to that dream forever.

At the March 28 board meeting a motion was made by Supervisor John Knight, seconded by Supervisor Ron Briggs, as follows: 1) Adopt the map establishing priority uses as follows: a) Segment 1-17.5 mile length from the county line through Latrobe to Mother Lode crossing as a multi-use trail including bike path and equestrian trail; b) Segment 2-6 mile length from Mother Lode crossing (mile marker 17.5) through Shingle Springs and El Dorado to Missouri Flat Road to be set aside as a joint multi-use trail for all trail users, historical railroad and an excursion train; c) Segment 3-Bike routes to the east of Missouri Flat Road existing Class 1 bike path, bike lanes, and bike route; 2) Direct staff to explore the feasibility and legality of removing the tracks in Segment 1 and consider if there are other alternatives to removing the tracks; and 3) Direct staff to return with further information on May 17.

Key words here are removing the tracks in Segment 1, which would not only be destroying a valuable historical resource in El Dorado County but, of course, would also make the dream of a large group of volunteers who have worked many hours and many years on the rail bed disappear.

So let your supervisor know how you feel about this issue and e-mail or write them soon. You can address letters to the Board of Supervisors, 360 Fair Lane, Placerville 95667 or go to the El Dorado County Website for e-mail addresses.
JOYCE THOMPSON
Kelsey

Keep the tracks

Editorials

Friday, April 15th, 2011 | Posted by Mountain Democrat

Don’t say I never warned you when your train gets lost.

— Bob Dylan

from the song “It Takes a Lot to Laugh, It Takes a Train to Cry.”

The El Dorado County Board of Supervisors is about to make the blunder of the century by agreeing to rip up the railroad tracks from Shingle Springs to the county line.

We’ll grant that nine miles from Shingle Springs to Diamond Springs may be enough track for the little bit of rolling stock the El Dorado County Museum volunteers have assembled.

We’ll also grant Supervisor Ray Nutting’s contention that the railroad ties west of Shingle Springs may not be in the best of shape and spikes could be loose.

But neither of those two arguments are sufficient to abandon a unique and irreplaceable asset. Ties can be replaced and spikes redriven. A real railroad right of way and its rails can never be replaced. To claim otherwise is believe in the Tooth Fairy and Daddy Warbucks.

Trails can be built alongside the rails. That, too, is a given. It is also a fact that building a paved  trail is expensive with or without the rails and requires extensive design and regrading. Just getting from Missouri Flat to Camino has cost thee county $8.5 milion. That came from special grants, but it didn’t happen in one year, despite having an entire rail-free right of way after Michigan-Cal Lumber Co. salvaged the rails from its private line and surrendered the right of way to the county and city. The city’s portion is not part of the $8.5 million and part of the city’s trail digresses from the original right of way. The whole trail that is now paved took over a decade to complete. Despite using an existing railroad right of way, regrading and new culverts had to be done. Creeks had flowed across the right of way and trees had grown up in the middle of it.

Before the Board of Supervisors so cavalierly surrenders 16 miles of track from Shingle Springs to the county line it had better consult with its other partners in the joint powers authority that governs the railroad right of way. Folsom has kept its line intact despite intensive commercial development. The rails cross major streets — Oak Avenue, Clarksville Road, Broadstone Parkway and Iron Point Road continuing along Placerville Road, eventually crossing into El Dorado County south of White Rock Road.

Folsom has a lot more resources, including a strong railroad volunteer support base, a rebuilt railroad turntable and now a revamped railroad museum. A serious excursion train effort is more likely to originate in Folsom and  travel to and through El Dorado County. El Dorado County still has the signal equipment at its road crossings.

Except for the Napa Wine Train and seasonal train service between the Railroad Museum in Sacramento and Freeport, the Placerville branch line is the only existing track near a major urban center. It is a branch line that features a beautiful countryside that is an up-and-coming wine region.

Don’t rip up the future. The right of way is sufficient to keep the rails and build a trail too.